Talk:Eat On Up/@comment-32602006-20140322003733/@comment-32602006-20140322012915

Actually I'm not the one who originally marked it for deletion. That was Scary. I always cite whatever my reason is for adding a pasta to "48 Hours", unless it is a clear and obvious trollpasta.

You're right, creepy is subjective, but in this case I don't even see any atempts at creepyness or even just being dark in general. The whole story is that the narrator ate some bad food and it gave him reflux and then the runs. Unless this is suppossed to indicate that he was poisoned or something, I don't see how that could possibly be construed as a creepypasta.

But beyond all that, this was in "Needs work" for over a month. That's the reason it was originally marked for deletion, not the fact that it was terribad to begin with.